Jordan Elsass Exits 'Superman & Lois' Series; Jonathan Kent Role To Be Recast

17 hours ago, Reno said:

I'm generally not a big fan of characters being recast, but sometimes it's just in the best interests of both the individual and the show. In this case, I truly hope that young Mr. Elsass gets whatever help that he needs and can continue to live a long and healthy life and career. I really enjoyed him as Jonathan Kent on the show and hope to see more of his work down the line, but his personal and mental health always has to come first of course.

I got no problems with recast. What a lot of people don't understand in today's market is that it's supposed to be about the story. The actors they cast should honestly be irrelevant if the story is good. Sure you don't wanna cast an 80 year old man as Superman and you want someone whose a fairly good actor to pull of the part but that's the job of the casting director to find the fit. If a person leaves that role for any reason, there's no reason they couldn't find another fit. Jordan's Jonathan Kent, though well done, is not the be all, end all definitive version of the character. He's not irreplaceable. He's not the only person capable of doing the part. Most actors will say the don't want to be defined by one role, anyway. Best wishes to Jordan and I hope he gets the help he needs.

I'm probably in the minority, but I wouldn't have actually minded all that much if they had recast even Black Panther after Chadwick Boseman passed, rest his soul. Sure it would have been a little awkward seeing another person in the role, but again, if the story/movie is good it would have been fine. Boseman was great in the role, but the character was there long before him and he didn't define the character and the character didn't define him. In all honesty I really think he had more memorable roles. Never casting the character again does not honor the role of BP. Never allowing anyone to play the character does not honor legacy of the character. Letting someone else play the part and allowing them to do the character justice and give it the respect the last person is the right way to honor the character.

I'm generally not a big fan of characters being recast, but sometimes it's just in the best interests of both the individual and the show. In this case, I truly hope that young Mr. Elsass gets whatever help that he needs and can continue to live a long and healthy life and career. I really enjoyed him as Jonathan on the show and hope to see more of his work down the line, but his personal and mental health always has to come first of course.